Head Coach Ronny Deila brought Taty Castellanos and Maxime Chanot back into his lineup after the pair served one-match suspensions for yellow card accumulation over the weekend.
City got the job done on that occasion, ousting the Montreal Impact 3-1 at Yankee Stadium, but this time NYC were facing off against a familiar foe who had inflicted defeat on them twice already in 2020.
Returning to East Hartford, the temporary home of Toronto FC, NYCFC made a bright start to the teams' fourth clash of the season, dominating possession from the get-go.
There were numerous chances for Castellanos in the first period, as Maxi Moralez, Keaton Parks and Jesus Medina all combined beautifully to fashion opportunities but Quentin Westberg could not be beaten in the Toronto goal and it was Toronto who went closest in the first half when a rare shot on goal from Nick DeLeon hit the post.
The best opportunity of the first 45' for the road team fell for Taty on 29' but his fiercely struck effort was blocked by Westberg and, as as they did at Red Bull Arena on their last meeting, the teams went in somehow level despite NYCFC's domination.
Fearing a repeat of the suckerpunch encountered with the luckless late penalty in September's match, NYCFC kept up the pressure after the break and it didn't take long for them to get their reward.
The irrepressible Castellanos created the goal, hitting a thunderous shot towards goal which Westberg could only parry out to Medina who did the rest, opening up his body and slotting into the corner for his fourth goal of the regular season - and second vs. Toronto in 2020.
That put the Paraguayan joint-top of the goalscoring rankings for the regular season along with Anton Tinnerholm, and he could've gone out on top on his own if his volley at the back post had been on target from a cross midway through the second half, but unfortunately for Jesus, his shot went the wrong side of the post when he might've scored.
Acevedo, Sebastien Ibeagha and Gudi Thórarinsson were introduced as the second half wore on with TFC pushing on for the equalizer and NYC still carrying a threat on the break.
It was City who looked the most dangerous on their breaks as the hosts' committed men forward, but there would be no more scoring, meaning Deila's men held on for all three points, levelling the seasonal head-to-head vs. Toronto at 2-2.
Next up, it's a Hudson River Derby in the Bronx on Sunday as City step up their quest for a top four spot.
Autore: Stefano Bentivogli
Other news - Focus
Other news
- 20:29 NYCFC’s World Cup Adventure Begins: When and Where to Watch Every Match Featuring the Club’s International Stars
- 08:01 Victor Wembanyama Silences Madison Square Garden as Spurs Revive NBA Finals Against Knicks
- 16:13 USMNT Loses to Germany, but One Performance Has Fans Dreaming Big Before the World Cup
- 16:09 FIFA Under Pressure as Iran World Cup Visa Controversy Raises Questions About Tournament Access
- 15:59 Trump at Knicks Game 3 Sparks Fan Backlash: “He’s Ruining the Finals Experience”
- 23:54 Jalen Brunson Just Passed Michael Jordan in a Stunning Playoff Stat — and Knicks Fans Are Losing It
- 23:05 New York City FC Loans Forward Zidane Yañez to Huntsville City FC
- 23:03 Spurs Defender Sends Warning to Jalen Brunson Before NBA Finals: “I’m Excited for the Challenge”
- 10:31 NYCFC Fall in Nashville Despite Fernández Mercau’s Heroics Before World Cup Break
- 10:27 Knicks One Step From the NBA Finals: Cleveland Collapses Again as New York Dominates Game 3
- 15:00 Columbus Crew’s Tactical Makeover: Why Henrik Rydström Could Cause NYCFC Real Problems
- 13:00 NYCFC Under Pressure to Respond: Pascal Jansen Demands Immediate Bounce Back
- 09:01 OG Anunoby Injury Mystery Keeps Knicks Fans Waiting: Game 4 Decision Could Change Everything
- 23:31 Injury Crisis Hits NYCFC Ahead of Columbus Clash: Pascal Jansen Faces Major Selection Problem
- 23:00 Mike Brown Drops Hilarious Jalen Brunson Quote After Knicks Silence Philadelphia
- 22:00 Knicks Prove They Can Survive Without OG Anunoby as Game 3 Sends Huge Message
- 21:07 NYCFC vs Columbus Crew: Yankee Stadium Clash Could Spark a Major MLS Turning Point
- 17:30 Pascal Jansen Sends Calm NYCFC Message After Wild 4-4 Draw: “We’ll Get It Right”
- 16:29 NYCFC Face a New-Look Montréal: Tactical Twist Could Decide Road Clash
- 15:22 NYCFC Hit by Injury Blow Before Montréal Clash: Four Players Ruled Out
- 22:00 Why Citi Field Could Be NYCFC’s Biggest Weapon in the Eastern Conference Race
- 21:34 NYCFC vs Charlotte FC Could Be an MLS Goal Fest — And Citi Field Might See Fireworks
- 21:32 NYCFC Hit by Injury Crisis Ahead of Charlotte Clash — Key Absences Could Change Everything
- 13:00 Dream Signings or Fantasy? Why NYCFC Could Chase Salah or Bernardo Silva This Summer
- 11:00 Shaq Questions Towns’ Mentality: Is KAT the Knicks’ Biggest X-Factor or Weak Link?
- 09:41 NYCFC Shut Out in Vancouver: Missed Chances Cost Them in Crucial Conference Clash
- 14:00 Same System, Different Souls: Why NYCFC vs Whitecaps Is a Tactical Chess Match
- 13:00 NYCFC vs Whitecaps: History Favors New York, but Vancouver’s Home Form Tells a Different Story
- 11:49 NYCFC Faces a Defining Test in Vancouver: Can Jansen’s Side Bounce Back on the Road?
- 14:00 Did Jansen Wait Too Long? NYCFC’s Late Substitutions Cost Them Victory
- 13:00 NYCFC’s Costly Habit Returns: Why Dropped Points Could Ruin Their 2026 Season
- 08:22 “We Can Beat Anyone”: Karl-Anthony Towns Fires Up Knicks With Bold Playoff Warning
- 20:00 Bernardo Silva Set to Leave Man City: MLS Move or European Giants Battle?
- 19:00 NYCFC’s Hidden Weakness? Why Matt Freese Needs Support Despite Stellar Form
- 18:00 NYCFC’s Defensive Wall Is Real: Why Opponents Are Struggling to Break Through
- 17:16 Brunson Breaks Atlanta’s Fortress: Knicks Win Thriller After Controversial Buzzer-Beater Drama
- 16:38 NYCFC’s Costly Flaw Exposed: Why One Missing Piece Ruined Victory Against St. Louis
- 21:00 NYCFC Must Solve St. Louis’ New-Look System as Familiar Face Returns to New York
- 20:00 NYCFC Eye Strong Response at Citi Field as St. Louis Arrive with Fresh Momentum
- 18:59 NYCFC Return to Citi Field with Big Ambitions: Can Queens Become Their Fortress in 2026?
- 18:34 NYCFC Hit by Injury Crisis Ahead of St. Louis Clash: Five Players Ruled Out
- 15:40 “It’s a joke!” — Mike Brown explodes over OG Anunoby’s All-Defense snub
- 16:29 Knicks Nightmare: Miles McBride Injured Again in Emotional Return Game
- 08:25 Knicks Collapse Late as Thunder Take Over: What Went Wrong in the Fourth Quarter
- 12:51 Etihad Park Milestone: NYCFC’s Dream Stadium Takes Major Step Toward 2027 Debut
- 12:10 Stephen A. Smith Fires Back at Josh Hart as Knicks Drama Reaches Boiling Point
- 10:00 Hornets Shock Knicks: Knueppel’s Breakout Game Ends New York’s Winning Streak
- 08:07 Internationals | Seven New York City FC Players Called Up for International Duty in March