The story of New York City FC's 1-1 draw against Toronto FC Wednesday at Yankee Stadium was the calls made along the way. And the calls that were not made.
Referee Chris Penso whistled two penalties for TFC (one converted), while NYCFC's goal came off a free kick. But the flashpoint for the game was in second-half stoppage time, in a sequence that left NYCFC forward Valentin Castellanos bleeding profusely from his nose.
Castellanos and Toronto defender Chris Mavinga got tangled up in a pursuit in Toronto's box. Castellanos took a touch on a long ball over the top with his head, and was blocked from running onto it by another Toronto defender Omar Gonzalez. Mavinga was in position to take possession, and Castellanos pulled on his jersey from behind. Mavinga then hit Castellanos in the face with a wayward hand, and both players were sent sprawling, Castellanos bleeding.
While it looked like Castellanos could earn a penalty and a red card for the contact sustained, Penso in fact whistled the foul on Castellanos for the jersey tug, and the officiating crew explained in writing after the match to pool reporter Dylan Butler that Castellanos' injury was sustained when play was dead.
Autore: Stefano Bentivogli
Other news - News
Other news
- 16:29 Knicks Nightmare: Miles McBride Injured Again in Emotional Return Game
- 08:25 Knicks Collapse Late as Thunder Take Over: What Went Wrong in the Fourth Quarter
- 12:51 Etihad Park Milestone: NYCFC’s Dream Stadium Takes Major Step Toward 2027 Debut
- 12:10 Stephen A. Smith Fires Back at Josh Hart as Knicks Drama Reaches Boiling Point
- 10:00 Hornets Shock Knicks: Knueppel’s Breakout Game Ends New York’s Winning Streak
- 08:07 Internationals | Seven New York City FC Players Called Up for International Duty in March
- 19:29 A Piece of History: Lionel Messi’s Match-Worn Anniversary Jersey Comes to Market
- 11:09 NYCFC vs Inter Miami: Eastern Giants Collide in a High-Stakes Bronx Showdown
- 23:13 Talles Magno Is Back: NYCFC Star Scores First Goal Since 2024 in Breakout Performance
- 16:03 NYCFC Survive Late First-Half Scare to Secure Third Straight Victory
- 12:52 NYCFC May Have Found Its New Goal Machine: Fernández Mercau Steps Up in Stunning Fashion
- 10:00 NYCFC Stay Red-Hot in 2026: Fernández Shines Again as New York Return to the Top
- 14:30 NYCFC Are Flying Early in 2026 — But Pascal Jansen Says the Best Is Still to Come
- 13:00 Colorado Rapids Arrive in Form: Why NYCFC Must Stop Rafael Navarro to Stay on Top
- 00:01 NYCFC’s Flying Start: Can the Boys in Blue Keep the Momentum Against Colorado?
- 21:57 NYCFC Hit by Triple Injury Blow Ahead of Colorado Clash at Yankee Stadium
- 21:51 Knicks Eye Draft Gem While Monitoring Giannis: Could Morez Johnson Jr. Be New York’s Future?
- 13:00 NYCFC Dominated the Galaxy but Only Scored Once – Now Philadelphia Union Could Make Them Pay
- 11:51 NYCFC, Parks: "I'm happy to finally be back"
- 11:35 NYCFC, Jansen: "We're focused on scoring more goals"
- 12:56 No Draws Since 2021: Why NYCFC vs Union Is Always Decided by One Goal
- 11:47 Knicks Shock Milwaukee: 29-Point Blowout Sends Eastern Conference Warning
- 23:11 Union’s Busy Schedule Could Be NYCFC’s Golden Opportunity
- 21:08 NYCFC Return to Scene of Playoff Triumph—Can They Strike Again in Chester?
- 01:14 Knicks Ranked Top-4… But the Week Told Two Stories: Contender Grit or Warning Sign?
- 00:10 Orlando City punishing in talks to sign Griezmann
- 09:01 NYCFC Stuns LA Galaxy Comeback Bid Falls Just Short: Mercau’s Ice-Cold Penalty Secures Opening Point
- 16:04 Casemiro to Join Messi? Inter Miami Plot Shock MLS Move as Man United Exit Looms
- 14:51 Messi Meltdown in LA: Inter Miami Crushed 3-0 as Son Steals the MLS Spotlight
- 09:24 Knicks Stun Rockets in Wild Comeback: From 18 Down to Garden Glory
- 09:22 NYCFC, Trio Miss Season Opener
- 01:00 MLS Transfer Shock? LA Galaxy Target Philippe Coutinho as NYCFC Lurks
- 23:00 OFFICIAL - LA Galaxy Waive Forward Christian Ramirez
- 20:04 Pascal Jansen: "We're ready, we want to do better than last year"
- 19:16 Trump Calls Out Cristiano Ronaldo: Viral MLS Message Sparks Global Debate
- 14:00 A New Era Begins: NYCFC Confirms Historic Etihad Park Debut for 2027–28 Season
- 01:30 Coast-to-Coast Challenge: NYCFC’s Season Begins with a High-Stakes Showdown in Los Angeles
- 23:00 NYCFC Is Finally Back: 85 Days Later, the MLS Reset Could Change Everything
- 22:19 New York City FC Signs 2026 MLS SuperDraft Pick Kevin Pierre to a First Team Contract
- 12:43 New York City FC Acquires $50,000 in GAM from St. Louis CITY SC
- 12:42 New York City FC Loans Forward Jovan Mijatović to Eintracht Braunschweig
- 12:40 LeBron James Madison Square Garden Farewell? Fans Pay Record Prices for Potential Last Game
- 17:43 NYCFC Go Global Again: Australian Defender Kai Trewin Set for MLS Switch
- 00:17 A Year In, Pascal Jansen Is Changing the Culture at NYCFC — and He’s Not Afraid to Say It Out Loud
- 23:08 Not Just a Breakout — Haak Is Entering His Star Era With the LA Galaxy
- 22:20 Castellanos: "I like London, it's like New York"
- 00:09 Jack Harrison’s Incredible Journey: From NYCFC Prodigy to Fiorentina’s New Hope
- 00:03 Warriors Desperate After Butler Injury: Is Karl-Anthony Towns the Last Big Swing?