Dome Torrent believes the referee "100 percent" made a mistake that cost New York City FC in Sunday's 2-1 Hudson River Derby loss to the New York Red Bulls.
A 60th-minute header by midfielder Daniel Royer gave the Red Bulls the match-winning lead, but it was a controversial non-call in the build-up to the goal that proved to be the match's main talking point.
In the preceding play, NYCFC thought they had conceded a corner, a point backed up by the linesman pointing with his flag to signal as such. Instead, the Red Bulls took a quick throw-in -- catching NYCFC, who were setting up for a corner, in limbo -- and Cristian Casseres Jr. crossed into the box where Royer headed it beyond goalkeeper Sean Johnson.
The right call was in fact a throw-in, but referee Alan Kelly never signalled that he was overriding the linesman's call. NYCFC head coach Torrent told Kelly that the lack of a clear signal was the deciding factor in his team's loss at Red Bull Arena.
"I say: 'You make a mistake and you know that.' He know that, he know that 100 percent," Torrent said after the match.
"You have to review on the TV if you don't. It's clear. It's not just one second, it's three seconds."
NYCFC captain Alex Ring backed up Torrent's comments, before accusing referee Kelly of being "part of the Red Bull team."
"It's just a shame to lose the points because I think the referee had a horrible game today," Ring said.
"He doesn't say anything, he just let the play continue as if he is part of the Red Bull team.
"I think it is just common decency. If it's that clear, the linesman shows to the corner flag -- I agree that it is a throw-in because I saw it the same way and then you let everyone know.
"I talked with a couple of Red Bull players who were surprised as well. I think we have to speak about this because it is not the first time we've had games go against us because of the referee."
What happened after the goal was organized chaos around Kelly, with nearly every NYCFC player on the field surrounding him angrily for several minutes. The protests continued after the match, with players and the staff arguing as Kelly walked off the field and through the tunnel at Red Bull Arena.
Alex Muyl, who made the quick decision to take a throw-in, didn't see the linesman signal a corner kick. He also didn't see any indication from Kelly that it was a throw-in or any other call. He just threw the ball in.
"For me, it was clearly a throw-in, that's why I threw it in," Muyl told ESPN FC. "If I had seen him put a corner, I would have gotten ready for a corner."
Other news - News
Other news
- 14:00 Knicks Regret Firing Thibodeau? Mike Brown’s Fast-Paced System Sparks Early Turmoil
- 13:00 Nashville SC Keep Playoff Dreams Alive with 2–1 Win Over Inter Miami — Game 3 Awaits
- 12:11 Heartbreak in the Bronx: NYCFC Fall to Charlotte FC in Dramatic Penalty Shootout
- 20:00 NYCFC Eyes First-Ever Road Win vs. Charlotte FC — and Gets a Big Break with Zaha Suspended
- 18:00 NYCFC’s Fate Rests on Alonso Martínez and Hannes Wolf — Can the Stars End Their Scoring Drought in the Playoffs?
- 16:00 Thiago Martins: NYCFC Captain Embraces Leadership Role Ahead of Playoffs
- 14:00 Matt Freese: NYCFC’s Breakout Star Earns MLS Goalkeeper of the Year Nomination — and Pascal Jansen Credits His ‘Growth Mindset’
- 12:00 Knicks Emerging as Top Contender for Giannis Antetokounmpo Amid Trade Buzz
- 11:00 Pascal Jansen on NYCFC’s ‘Bulletproof Mindset’: The Mental Edge Driving Their Playoff Push
- 10:00 Knicks Score Long-Term Win With Mikal Bridges’ “Discount” Contract Extension
- 09:00 The Jennifer Lopez Glow Arrives in Umbria: HydraFacial at Tenuta Fogliani Resort & Natural SPA
- 08:32 MLS: Seattle and Columbus lose in Game 1, but Minnesota and Cincinnati win early
- 23:01 NYCFC vs Charlotte FC: Pascal Jansen Missing Key Trio Ahead of Saturday Night Clash
- 15:49 Pascal Jansen Confident Ahead of Charlotte Clash: “We Were Dominant — Now It’s Time to Take Our Chances”
- 11:00 The Secret to a Relaxing Holiday in Umbria: Tenuta Fogliani Resort & Natural Spa
- 08:54 Pascal Jansen Rallies NYCFC: “The Moment Is Here” as Playoffs Begin Against Charlotte FC
- 23:27 New York City FC Set to Face Charlotte FC in Thrilling MLS Cup Playoffs Round One Best-of-3 Showdown
- 14:23 Heartbreak at Citi Field: NYCFC Fall 2-1 to Seattle Sounders After Late Drama on Decision Day
- 14:00 NYCFC Bids Emotional Farewell to David Lee After 11 Years: “One of MLS’s Most Respected Sporting Directors”
- 12:00 David Lee Bids Farewell to NYCFC: “This Team Has an Incredible Future Ahead”
- 08:00 Shock in MLS: David Lee Leaves NYCFC After a Decade to Join Sporting Kansas City
- 15:45 Messi Close to Signing New Contract with Inter Miami Until 2028
- 10:55 NYCFC Transfers Mounsef Bakrar to GNK Dinamo Zagreb
- 10:39 NYCFC Defeats Club León 2-0 in Leagues Cup Clash: Goals from Martínez and Ojeda, Freese Shines in Goal
- 17:00 Alonso Martínez Named Player of the Match in NYCFC’s 4–3 Win Over FC Dallas
- 15:58 Rodrigo De Paul Unveiled as Inter Miami's Newest Star Before Cincinnati Match
- 15:43 Martínez Hat-Trick Powers NYCFC to 4–3 Thriller Over FC Dallas
- 15:38 Sebastiano Musu Signs Third Short-Term Deal with New York City FC
- 14:00 Mario Balotelli to MLS? Alessio Sundas Pushes for NYCFC Move in Bold Career Revival Bid
- 12:00 Etihad Player of the Month | Thiago Martins Scoops May Award
- 10:00 Italian Agent Alessio Sundas Aims to Revolutionize MLS with European Talent
- 08:06 Eight City Players Called Up for International Duty in June
- 12:30 Alessio Sundas Eyes MLS Revolution: After Balotelli, Gattuso Could Be Next
- 01:09 Hannes Wolf’s Late Heroics Rescue 2-2 Draw for NYCFC in Thrilling Comeback Against Nashville SC
- 19:00 NYCFC Aim to Reset vs. Nashville: “Time to Show Consistency” Says Jansen
- 18:00 Jansen Eyes Strong Start vs. Nashville: “Scoring First Changes Everything”
- 17:00 NYCFC Aim to Bounce Back Against Nashville SC: Jansen Calls for a Return to Identity
- 16:44 Mario Balotelli Eyes MLS Move: A New American Dream in the Works?
- 06:00 Injury Woes for NYCFC Ahead of Houston Clash: Four Key Players Ruled Out
- 04:00 Jansen Stresses Training Ground Mentality as Key to NYCFC Lineup Choices
- 02:00 NYCFC Gets Injury Boost as Keaton Parks Returns, but Caution Remains for Key Players
- 23:00 Jansen’s NYCFC Looks to Build Momentum With Big Night Under the Lights
- 22:20 Seymour Reid Signs Homegrown Deal With NYCFC – A Star in the Making Joins the First Team
- 14:00 Can NYCFC Ride the Momentum? Quick Turnaround Offers Opportunity Against Houston
- 12:00 NYCFC Extends Unbeaten Streak vs. Chicago Fire with Another Statement Win
- 09:51 Mounsef Bakrar Silences Doubts with Crucial Goal in NYCFC Comeback
- 16:00 NYCFC eye momentum: a pivotal home clash to spark an eastern conference climb
- 14:00 Chaos vs. Control: NYCFC and Chicago Fire Set for Explosive Showdown at Yankee Stadium
- 12:00 NYCFC vs. Chicago Fire: Can the Boys in Blue End Chicago’s Scorching Run at Yankee Stadium?
- 10:54 NYCFC vs. Chicago Fire: Key Absences for Jansen’s Side Ahead of Crucial MLS Clash